KVM scalability and consolidation ratio: cache none vs cache writeback

Written by Gionatan Danti on . Posted in Virtualization

User Rating:  / 8
PoorBest 

Host scalability: memory utilization

Do using some RAM for caching lowers total free memory? Lets check:

This chart really need an explanation. The “MEM (w/cache)” line shows total system memory usage, while the “MEM (w/out cache)” shows real memory utilization. The key concept here is that for Linux (and other modern OSes are the same) the memory used for caching and/or buffering is not really maked as “used memory”, as it can readily freed at any time.

So, real memory utilization is depicted by the red line. Watching this line, you can see that the wb-cache is no more memory-hungry that the nocache configuration.

In other words: Linux only engages unused memory for caching and, when an application requires more free memory, it immediately deallocs cache for giving the application the requested memory.

The careful reader should have a question now: how it is possible for a 8 GB host machine to happily run as much as 12 virtual machines, for a total estimated guest memory usage of over 9 GB, without heavy swapping? The answer lie in a very useful Linux feature, called KSM (kernel samepage merging). KSM enable the host system to periodically check for duplicate memory chunks, and to deduplicate them when found. In short, if two memory locations have the same content, KSM marks the first location as a CoW (copy-on-write) one, and frees the second location. If an application want to modify the shared location, the system first re-duplicate it, and then modify the newly-created location.

In practice KSM works surprisingly well, especially for short-lived Windows machines: as Windows has the habit of zeroing all free memory at startup, KSM has plenty of opportunities to coalesce these zeroed pages.

Comments   

 
#1 Troels Arvin 2014-01-20 20:24
Where can one read more about the potential issues with write barriers and live migration?
 
 
#2 Gionatan Danti 2014-01-21 10:20
Quoting Troels Arvin:
Where can one read more about the potential issues with write barriers and live migration?


Hi,
here you can find some informations on barriers:
http://www.ilsistemista.net/index.php/virtualization/23-kvm-storage-performance-and-cache-settings-on-red-hat-enterprise-linux-62.html?start=2

On live migration and why it is better to not use it with caching, you can read libvirt and qemu man page.

Regards.
 

You have no rights to post comments